Fiercely
Independent

Fauci’s Fate Rests With Prosecutors After Senate Votes to Hold Him With Content

by Matthias Browning

Anthony Fauci was a controversial figure during COVID.Image: Christopher Michel, Wikipedia Commons

The Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee’s party-line vote to hold Dr. Anthony Fauci in contempt of Congress marks the start of a legal process, not the end of one.

What happens from here depends on decisions by federal prosecutors, a grand jury, and potentially a judge — with no guarantee the effort will ever produce a conviction, or even formal charges.

Normally, a contempt resolution approved by committee moves to the full Senate floor, where it would need enough support to pass before being certified and sent to the Justice Department. Committee Chairman Rand Paul chose to skip that step.

He said his office would hand-deliver the referral directly to the Department of Justice and the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Washington, arguing he did not want to lose time on a floor vote he likely could not win outright given the chamber’s rules.

That shortcut is legally contested. Some legal observers note that under the federal contempt statute, a committee can refer a case to the Senate president — currently Vice President JD Vance — as an alternative to a full chamber vote, which would still let Paul avoid a floor fight while following a recognized procedural path.

Others argue that skipping Senate passage altogether could leave the referral vulnerable to a defense challenge later, since courts have generally expected the chamber itself to have signed off before a contempt case reaches prosecutors.

The Justice Department has acknowledged receiving Paul’s referral and said only that it is reviewing the matter.

Congress cannot prosecute or convict anyone on its own; that power belongs to the executive branch. Once the U.S. Attorney’s Office reviews the referral, it must decide whether to bring the matter before a grand jury.

If prosecutors move forward and a grand jury agrees to indict, Fauci would then face the actual criminal process — arraignment, pretrial motions, and potentially a trial — before any contempt charge could stick.

Contempt of Congress is a federal misdemeanor. A conviction could carry a fine of up to $100,000 and up to a year in prison, though nothing in the process guarantees the case gets that far.

Legal analysts have described the Justice Department’s calculation as unusually complicated, both because of Fauci’s pardon and because of open questions about whether his Fifth Amendment claim was valid in the first place.

Advertisement

Before leaving office, President Biden granted Fauci a broad pardon covering conduct going back roughly a decade, intended to protect him from prosecutions Biden characterized as politically motivated.

Paul and other Republicans argue that pardon is precisely why Fauci had no right to invoke the Fifth Amendment during his July 29 testimony — in their view, a person who cannot be charged for past conduct has nothing left to incriminate himself about.

Fauci’s defenders reject that reasoning. They point out the pardon only covers actions taken up through the date it was signed; it does nothing to shield him from prosecution over statements or conduct in this year’s testimony itself, including any allegation — however unproven so far — that he misled the committee.

Legal scholars have also noted that the Fifth Amendment can still apply even to a pardoned witness if answering truthfully could expose him to other legal jeopardy, such as a state-level charge or a false-statement allegation tied to the current hearing.

Whether a federal court will ultimately side with Paul’s reading of the pardon or with Fauci’s broader Fifth Amendment claim is likely to become the central legal question if the case advances.

Republican committee members have been vocal that they expect prosecution to follow. Democrats on the panel opposed the contempt vote and warned it sets a troubling precedent for how committees treat witnesses going forward, particularly one chairman acting largely on his own authority to trigger a criminal referral against a private citizen.

That tension — a high-profile political push for accountability colliding with genuine legal ambiguity — is likely to define the coming weeks. The Justice Department’s response will signal how seriously it takes the referral; a grand jury’s decision, if it gets that far, will test whether prosecutors can actually make a contempt case stick against a pardoned witness who says he was protecting himself from further legal exposure.

Congress returns from its August recess in the coming weeks, and Paul has left open the possibility of still pursuing a full Senate vote if the Justice Department route stalls.

For now, the practical next step is procedural rather than dramatic: prosecutors reviewing a file, deciding whether the facts and the law support moving forward, and weighing a case that sits at the unusual intersection of a presidential pardon, a Fifth Amendment claim, and a congressional committee’s demand for answers about a pandemic that ended years ago but has never stopped being politically contested.

Our biggest stories, straight to your inbox

Sign up now to get the latest news from around the world

Popular

Podcasts »Visit ChannelC